Checked against public sources, physician reviewed

New to Key West: establishing care

Not sure this is your page? Two quick questions at which doctor do I need will point you right.

The whole job in one paragraph: pick your primary care model, request your records before you need them, build a medication bridge so nothing runs out mid-move, and book the establish visit before season starts. Do those four things and the island's healthcare quirks, one hospital, a short physician roster, a December-to-April squeeze, become background noise instead of emergencies. The checklist below turns each one into something you can do today.

The establish-care checklist

  1. Choose the model. A traditional PCP suits most people; the primary care guide covers the island's realities. Frequent access needs or a two-address year point toward the membership model. If your care runs mostly on follow-ups and prescriptions, a telehealth-first setup can carry real weight. Do today: pick one model and two candidate practices.
  2. Request your records now. Under HIPAA you have a federal right of access to your records, and practices generally must act within 30 days of the request (HHS.gov). Do today: call your old practice and ask for its release process, or sign the new office's request form.
  3. Build the medication bridge. Ask your current prescriber for 90-day fills, then transfer prescriptions to a local or mail-order pharmacy once you land. Controlled substances usually need a local prescriber sooner rather than later. Do today: list every medication with doses and count the days of supply you actually hold.
  4. Book the establish visit before season. October beats January here, every year: Monroe County's visitor studies put the island at its fullest from December through April, and appointment supply moves opposite to the crowds. Do today: call and take the first establish slot on the books, even if it is weeks out.
  5. The snowbird rule: leave one appointment ahead. Before flying north, book next season's first visit. You will land in November already on the schedule instead of dialing into the January rush. Do today if you are leaving soon: put that appointment on the books before you pack.
  6. Learn the emergency routing before you need it. The island's hospital is Lower Keys Medical Center on Stock Island, with the region's 24-hour emergency department; for emergencies the answer is 911, full stop. Do today: read the red-flag list below once, so the thresholds are familiar before anything hurts.

What season does to your timeline

From the island's point of view, the year has two speeds. May through November, offices have room, records departments answer quickly, and an establish visit books in days or a couple of weeks. December through April, the same calls compete with the winter population, and some practices pause new patients entirely. None of this is a crisis if you time around it; all of it is a wall if you discover it in January. If you arrive mid-season anyway, work the checklist in the same order and take the first establish slot offered, even weeks out, while asking to join every cancellation list. Until you are established, same-day needs are their own problem with their own playbook: the see-a-doctor-today guide covers that gap.

The two-address records problem

Seasonal residents run two doctors, two states, and one body, and the failure mode is two charts that never meet. The fix is boring discipline: tell each doctor the other exists, carry one medication list that both offices hold, and after any significant visit up north, ask that office to send the summary south (and the reverse in spring). Medicare's Care Compare tool at medicare.gov is the standard way to find participating doctors after a move, and it works the same for a second address. Ask three questions of both offices: who manages which conditions, who owns the medication list, and which office handles refills in which months. Write the answers down once and the system runs itself. For a first summer on the island, the seasonal health side, heat, sun, stings, and the mosquito calendar, is Doctor Key West's beat; its mosquitoes and dengue column is the one to read before your first rainy season.

Where to start: verified local practices

These practices cover the two establish-care models: traditional primary care and membership medicine. Availability changes, please call ahead to confirm.

Baptist Health Concierge Medicine Key West

Concierge, Primary care

(305) 419-6490

1111 12th Street, Suite 109, Key West, FL 33040

listed from public directory, not yet phone-verified

Availability changes, please call ahead to confirm.

Keys Medical Group Primary Care at Searstown

Primary care, Telehealth

(305) 293-4073

3224 North Roosevelt Boulevard, Key West, FL 33040

Telehealth advertised

listed from public directory, not yet phone-verified

Availability changes, please call ahead to confirm.

Norris Healthcare Concierge

Concierge, Primary care

(305) 998-4205

1010 Kennedy Drive, Suite 402, Key West, FL 33040

listed from public directory, not yet phone-verified

Availability changes, please call ahead to confirm.

Womankind

Women's health, Primary care, Mental health

(305) 294-4004

1511 Truman Avenue, Key West, FL 33040

listed from public directory, not yet phone-verified

Availability changes, please call ahead to confirm.

Frequently asked questions

How do I transfer my medical records to a new doctor?

Ask your old practice for a records release form, or sign the new practice's request form and let the offices handle it. Under HIPAA you have a federal right to your records, and practices generally must respond within 30 days. Start early: the transfer routinely takes longer than getting the appointment itself.

How far ahead should I book before season?

Aim to have your establish visit done by late fall. Between December and April the island fills, schedules pack, and some practices pause new patients. October is the sweet spot: offices have room, and you walk into season already established. Same-day or next-day appointments may be available. Availability changes, please call ahead to confirm.

Can I keep my doctor up north and have one here too?

Yes, and most seasonal residents should. Tell each doctor the other exists, keep one shared medication list, and ask both offices to send visit summaries to each other. Your northern doctor may also be able to see you by video while you are in Florida if they hold a Florida license or the state's out-of-state telehealth registration.

How do I move my prescriptions to Key West?

Ask your prescriber for 90-day fills before you move or fly south, then have your new pharmacy request the transfer; pharmacies handle the transfer directly for most medications. Controlled substances have tighter transfer rules and often need a new local prescriber, so sort those first, not last.

Sources

  • HHS, the HIPAA right of access to your health information: hhs.gov
  • Medicare, Care Compare provider search: medicare.gov
  • Monroe County Tourist Development Council visitor profile studies: monroecounty-fl.gov

© 2026 KeyWestDoc.